Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 37 of 64
Trump wanted to find money for pay rich people taxes by increase more taxes to the poor and middle class people.
Trump wanted to find money for pay rich people taxes by increase more taxes to the poor and middle class people.
Critiques Trump's tax policy as redistributing burden from wealthy to working and middle-class people.
@ToakCalifornia Mar 4, 2025
What I don't like is the millionaires that move our jobs out of our country to benefit themselves. My father lost a good manufacturing job because labor was cheaper in some other county. Now look …
What I don't like is the millionaires that move our jobs out of our country to benefit themselves. My father lost a good manufacturing job because labor was cheaper in some other county. Now look at Boeing. Somehow we need someone that is looking out for US! Trying to bring jobs and industry back to the USA. Trudeau is a terrible leader and I'm happy to see him squirm.
Focuses on job loss, outsourcing, and economic priorities, criticizing both corporate practices and Trudeau's leadership.
@themotofixery Mar 4, 2025
This is crazy. Everybody MUST realize, These US tarriffs, come out of American Pockets. Go directly to the Government. That is how Trump is financing the government. Fancy Immediate tax.
This is crazy. Everybody MUST realize, These US tarriffs, come out of American Pockets. Go directly to the Government. That is how Trump is financing the government. Fancy Immediate tax.
Explains tariffs as a government financing mechanism, analyzing economic impact and policy mechanism.
@robgandy4550 Mar 4, 2025
Just watching the Canadian peso drop ??
Just watching the Canadian peso drop ??
Comment about Canadian currency depreciation, focusing on economic impact of the political situation.
@bigfishy7816 Mar 4, 2025
I'd buy that guy on the bike a case of beer. It's so sad seeing guys like him who are so aware, who are obviously capable, having to live such poor lives. But this is …
I'd buy that guy on the bike a case of beer. It's so sad seeing guys like him who are so aware, who are obviously capable, having to live such poor lives. But this is Canada, where two people making the average income will never own a home and spend more than half their income on basics. That guy probably makes 50k a year. But is riding a bicycle in winter.
Primary focus is on economic hardship in Canada (housing costs, wages, cost of living) with empathy toward a struggling immigrant worker.
Полиграфович Jan 28, 2026
dude in front of the store smokin cigarette is thankful for their slave wages lol
dude in front of the store smokin cigarette is thankful for their slave wages lol
Critiques low wages paid to immigrant workers, expressing concern about labor exploitation.
maestrozilla Jan 28, 2026
Canada is not bringing in immigrants to work. I am a child of immigrants. My parents worked hard from the day they landed and given 0 from the government. Today, these "new Canadians " get …
Canada is not bringing in immigrants to work. I am a child of immigrants. My parents worked hard from the day they landed and given 0 from the government. Today, these "new Canadians " get free housing, free large amounts of money(which they use to send back to their homeland)...while we , born Canadians find it hard to pay our everyday expenses. Does this make sense.? The government has to stop handing out our hard earned money. Take care of your own first. And we have to endure bending to their culture not them learning our culture...our humility and kindness. This is not about to being welcoming to everyone , this is about calling out to the government start cleaning up this mess before we ( born Canadians) find ourselves without a country of our own.
Uses personal immigrant family background to argue new immigrants receive excessive government benefits while born Canadians struggle financially, mixing narrative with unverified welfare claims.
Rose-h4y3v Sep 8, 2025
tRump and Elon are holding the country hostage and taking all it's wealth and the MAGAT's are cheering, soon they will pay more for groceries, gas, homes and just about everything. the stock market are …
tRump and Elon are holding the country hostage and taking all it's wealth and the MAGAT's are cheering, soon they will pay more for groceries, gas, homes and just about everything. the stock market are plummeting and they are cheering and loosing their jobs because of DOGe, Canada need to fight back (and we will) even harder and make the red states pay against their products and services and farmers, it's not against the american people but the illegal tariffs, stay strong ??
Discusses economic consequences of Trump/Elon policies (inflation, job losses, stock market) and calls for Canadian retaliatory tariffs.
@mtlHc Mar 4, 2025
Us too All our companies Our poor data Also import from the world most polluted nation 😮 Our spices and food. Smh.
Us too All our companies Our poor data Also import from the world most polluted nation 😮 Our spices and food. Smh.
Critiques economic and environmental impacts of imports and foreign companies, expressing concern about data security and pollution.
amazon4716 Jan 28, 2026
Americans are sick of getting taking advantage of fair is fair even across the board period.
Americans are sick of getting taking advantage of fair is fair even across the board period.
Frames immigration through economic fairness and exploitation concerns, suggesting economic impact argument.
@jasonerickson1033 Mar 4, 2025
And these Muslims talk about how they are having babies and we are not. We are not having babies because we have to work to pay for them having their babies for their hospitals bills.
And these Muslims talk about how they are having babies and we are not. We are not having babies because we have to work to pay for them having their babies for their hospitals bills.
Frames immigration as economic burden on native citizens, claiming immigrants receive benefits while citizens struggle financially, with religious/ethnic targeting.
itsmemike60j54 Aug 28, 2025
My town got the invasion in the past couple of years, 90% of my business is now done with Indians. Tim's, fast food, deliveries, Walmart, CDN Tire, etc. Young people can't get a start in …
My town got the invasion in the past couple of years, 90% of my business is now done with Indians. Tim's, fast food, deliveries, Walmart, CDN Tire, etc. Young people can't get a start in the job market because the govt subsidizes their wages with our taxes.
Combines personal observation with economic concerns about job market competition and wage subsidization.
dlcarbonneau3750 Jan 28, 2026
Well, Americans can hear first-hand that Canada has gone above and beyond to maintain a peaceful, productive alliance. This will hurt the working class people in all countries associated, but the working class Americans more …
Well, Americans can hear first-hand that Canada has gone above and beyond to maintain a peaceful, productive alliance. This will hurt the working class people in all countries associated, but the working class Americans more than any other group. \n\nThis is a sad day in world history.
Acknowledges Canada's diplomatic efforts while emphasizing the economic harm to working-class people across countries, framing trade conflict as a moral tragedy.
@brendaglynn3052 Mar 4, 2025
Canada wanted foreigners to do the dirty work - menial work Millions of educated indians got green card - without having a job They came to canada - they found out 30% found jobs - …
Canada wanted foreigners to do the dirty work - menial work Millions of educated indians got green card - without having a job They came to canada - they found out 30% found jobs - 70% did low pay work And Brampton - brown town - erupted - symbol of Canadian Greed
Analyzes employment outcomes and wage disparities for educated immigrants, critiquing both immigration policy and employer exploitation.
Yjs11 Sep 21, 2025
Trump is going to screw up the economies all over the world and it’s not a good time for that
Trump is going to screw up the economies all over the world and it’s not a good time for that
Expresses concern about Trump's economic policies and their negative global impact, framed as an economic threat.
@BluesJames Mar 4, 2025
Inflation is to the roof, Make food and housing affordable, please people just help impeach him, he is golfing while the american people are struggling everyday.... He is just trying to pass stupid laws that …
Inflation is to the roof, Make food and housing affordable, please people just help impeach him, he is golfing while the american people are struggling everyday.... He is just trying to pass stupid laws that keep getting blocked by courts, Come on Trump supporters try helping fix it by calling your local office and impeach him, I bet anyone else is better than Trump, we know the country needs changes but we are still the biggest economy of the world the richest country, Why do we have to feel like is normal not to have affordable food and housing?? The basics of life... All the immigrants are gone, They even left by their own will, and Some Americans left to other countries, Mexico, Europe, Asia..... What do you guys want?? Having an empty country once was the biggest economy of the world?? Is just crazy even a blind person can see he is destroying the whole country..... He is not even a good business person we all know he didn't payed taxes, he went bankrupt so many times he knows how to scam people, Saying the USA government doesn't work because he feels like it, Just travel people so you can see the difference between usa government and other governments around the world........
Primarily focuses on inflation, housing, and food affordability as core economic grievances, with calls to action and international comparisons.
@KenRa469 Mar 4, 2025
3:47This happens because you guys are lazy and dont want to work and Indians work in your place you people have a problem with that too and Indians are 1000 times more hardworking than Canadians …
3:47This happens because you guys are lazy and dont want to work and Indians work in your place you people have a problem with that too and Indians are 1000 times more hardworking than Canadians Canada is 159 years old as if the land wasn’t already home to Indigenous peoples for thousands of years before you politely showed up and called it a country. Now teaching the world manners -- classic😂
Defends Indian workers' economic contribution and work ethic while critiquing Canadian laziness and historical colonialism.
Ibrahimmmh727 Jan 28, 2026
They got the poors blaming immigrants instead of the billionaires robbing them. Genius.
They got the poors blaming immigrants instead of the billionaires robbing them. Genius.
Critiques the framing of immigration as a scapegoat for economic inequality caused by billionaires and wealth concentration.
nicoj3660 Jan 28, 2026
Peope dont realise this but there is no stopping immigration in Canada. The stock market anticipates huge immigration as it is the only feasible path towards growing corporate profits. If we dont have huge immmigration, …
Peope dont realise this but there is no stopping immigration in Canada. The stock market anticipates huge immigration as it is the only feasible path towards growing corporate profits. If we dont have huge immmigration, the purchasing power of boomers, derived from a booming market and real estate market, will lead to massive inflation as labor shortages occur. There is nothing we can do to stop this. Boomers are going to vote Liberal and liberals will continue to flood the country with third world immigrants who cook, clean, drive, caretake, etc. Millenials and gen Z are the ones who will never own a home or start a family. And ironically the low birth rate will lead to even more immigration. I suspect that Canada will be primarily asian and african by 2060.
Presents a causal chain linking immigration to economic outcomes (stock market, housing, inflation) with unsubstantiated claims about demographic projections and generational impacts.
fansheetsadmin7278 Jun 21, 2025
Those Sun chips are a luxury. You want to afford chips? You gotta buy the Great Value 😒
Those Sun chips are a luxury. You want to afford chips? You gotta buy the Great Value 😒
Comments on affordability and consumer purchasing power in the context of economic hardship.
drest5316 Aug 27, 2025
« Prev 37 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)