Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Moral Argument

2,863 comments
Page 33 of 144
the way white people are hurt now, it was the same way red indians were hurt when white people occupied and colonised their free country
the way white people are hurt now, it was the same way red indians were hurt when white people occupied and colonised their free country
Appeals to historical justice and fairness by comparing current white displacement to Indigenous colonization, using moral equivalence argument.
SaraanSarangi Sep 19, 2025
It’s wonderful to see significant world figures standing up to a right wing lunatic. It’s brave, necessary and important.
It’s wonderful to see significant world figures standing up to a right wing lunatic. It’s brave, necessary and important.
Appeals to ethics and courage in standing against right-wing extremism, framing it as morally necessary.
@OTheQuietOneO Mar 4, 2025
TFW pay tax’s same like Canadian citizens and PR but TFW pay for basic rights Healthcare, School and others what a shame. TFW is scapegoating in upcoming referendum.
TFW pay tax’s same like Canadian citizens and PR but TFW pay for basic rights Healthcare, School and others what a shame. TFW is scapegoating in upcoming referendum.
Appeals to fairness and justice, arguing that temporary foreign workers face discriminatory treatment despite equal tax contributions.
@MohammadTareq-m6u Feb 20, 2026
I love my country and my people and what the government is doing is not right. We are decent people and don’t deserve this.
I love my country and my people and what the government is doing is not right. We are decent people and don’t deserve this.
Appeals to fairness and dignity of Canadian people while opposing government policy, grounded in moral principles of deservingness.
Lakeboii70 Aug 25, 2025
One thing I'd never understand is when Whites have invaded, colonized, pillaged entire continents they downplay it or straight up deny it, and now a few brownskins (not even making 10% of the population) are …
One thing I'd never understand is when Whites have invaded, colonized, pillaged entire continents they downplay it or straight up deny it, and now a few brownskins (not even making 10% of the population) are in their country doing their work, minding their own business and they call it invasion.
Appeals to historical justice and hypocrisy by contrasting Western colonialism with current immigration criticism, framed as moral inconsistency.
GrumpyAboutEverything Oct 4, 2025
WHITE PPL INVADED INDIA ; STOLE, KILLED 15 MILLION PPL... INDIAN PPL MOVE TO CANADA TO WORK...WHERE IS THE PROBLEM? ITS NOT EVEN YOUR COUNTRY, YOU STOLE IT TOO, REMEMBER THIEVES?
WHITE PPL INVADED INDIA ; STOLE, KILLED 15 MILLION PPL... INDIAN PPL MOVE TO CANADA TO WORK...WHERE IS THE PROBLEM? ITS NOT EVEN YOUR COUNTRY, YOU STOLE IT TOO, REMEMBER THIEVES?
Appeals to historical injustice and moral hypocrisy, comparing Canada's colonial history to current immigration, arguing immigration is justified on ethical grounds.
moneyslaves1945 Jan 27, 2026
Fuck u bro I don’t know what fucking hate you have towards Indians
Fuck u bro I don’t know what fucking hate you have towards Indians
Accusation of hatred toward Indians, appealing to fairness and condemning perceived discrimination in the video.
GaganParashar-s4k Jan 27, 2026
There was no reason on earth for Trump to start this trade war, except for Trump's desperate need to hurt people. He's mean.
There was no reason on earth for Trump to start this trade war, except for Trump's desperate need to hurt people. He's mean.
Moral judgment that Trump's trade war is motivated by malice ('desperate need to hurt people') rather than legitimate policy rationale.
@robertklose2140 Mar 4, 2025
8:32 polish man, bro you are standing naked, and giving interview and calling other people dirty... bro's claim "they don't work" your uber driver was working lol. and wtf with the line "they all look …
8:32 polish man, bro you are standing naked, and giving interview and calling other people dirty... bro's claim "they don't work" your uber driver was working lol. and wtf with the line "they all look alike" lol, that's racism you can get sued on this btw.
Calls out racist statements and stereotyping as ethically wrong and legally actionable, appealing to fairness principles.
ThomasHeisenberg-e5s Feb 28, 2026
This isn’t about left or right. It’s about truth, freedom, and the future. Trump thrives on division, fear, and power. without accountability.\n\nDemocracy dies when we stay silent. We can’t afford that. Stand up. Speak out. …
This isn’t about left or right. It’s about truth, freedom, and the future. Trump thrives on division, fear, and power. without accountability.\n\nDemocracy dies when we stay silent. We can’t afford that. Stand up. Speak out. The fight isn’t over.
Appeals to universal values (truth, freedom, democracy) to argue against Trump's divisive tactics, then urges civic engagement and resistance.
@BrianZiola-yt4ki Mar 5, 2025
Wait what about the native canadian people ? its okay for you to colonize and claim , but if someone else come and live peacefully , didnt your ancestors came to india for 300 years …
Wait what about the native canadian people ? its okay for you to colonize and claim , but if someone else come and live peacefully , didnt your ancestors came to india for 300 years and colonized and killd million ? oh the real problem is indians coming here
Appeals to historical justice and hypocrisy, arguing that Canada's colonial past undermines criticism of current immigration.
everengaged9370 Jan 27, 2026
⚠️ Freedom of Speech ≠ Freedom of Hate Speech. 1. Do they have any Valid Answer for Why They Hate Indians? 2. Do they have any Logical Explanation for How Indians are Harming People Across …
⚠️ Freedom of Speech ≠ Freedom of Hate Speech. 1. Do they have any Valid Answer for Why They Hate Indians? 2. Do they have any Logical Explanation for How Indians are Harming People Across the World? 📌 The Answer is NO. 👾 Any Negative Action or Thought By An Individual from India ≠ Every or Many Indians' Action or Thought. 👾 Minor Exceptions Do Not Represent Most of the Indians. 🤖 Spreading Hatred Because of a Minor or No Reason is a Sign of Poor Mental Condition or Lack of Proper Education & Awareness. 🇮🇳 India is Much Bigger than Someone's Imagination. 🇮🇳 Being An Indian is a Matter of Pride. 1. India is the World's Largest Democracy. 2. India is One of the World’s Oldest Civilizations. 3. India has the World's Oldest Religion. 4. India is One of the Most Diverse Countries in the World. 5. India is One of the Fastest-growing Major Economies in the World. 6. India is the 4th Largest Economy in the World. 7. India has One of the Fastest-growing Startup Ecosystems in the World. 8. India is the Home to 18% of Total Humanity on Earth. 9. India has One of the Most Influencial Cultural Diversities in the World. 10. India Produces World's 2nd Most STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering & Mathematics) Graduates Every Year. 11. India has One of the Largest Youth Work forces in the World. 12. India has the 2nd Largest Active Military Personnel in the World. 13. India is the 4th Powerful Military in the World. 14. India is the World's Pharmacy that Provides 20% of the World’s Generic Medicines. 15. India is the First Country to Reach Mars Orbit on its First Attempt. 16. India is the First Country to Land near the Moon’s South Pole. 17. Many Scientific & Mathematical Concepts Like Zero, Decimal System, Yoga, Astronomy, Metallurgy were Originated in India. 18. India has the World's Largest Highly Skilled Diaspora across the Countries. 19. India is the CEO Capital of the World leading World's Largest Corporations. 20. India has 3rd Highest Billionaires in the World. 21. About 11% of All the American Unicorn Startups are Co-founded by Indian Origin Citizens. 22. About 10% of Total US Patents are Attributed to the Indian-origin Inventors. 23. About 10% of Total US Physicians are of Indian Origin. 24. Indian Diaspora Contributes more than 5% of Total US Income Taxes Annually. 25. Indian Diaspora Contributes more than 5% of the UK’s Total GDP. 26. About 60% of all Hotels in the United States are Owned By Indian-origin Businessmen. 27. About 40% of all Convenience Stores in the US are Owned By Indian-origins. 28. Indian Origins are the Highest-earning Ethnic Group in the U.S. 29. Indian Diaspora Holds over 300 High-ranking Government Positions Across the Countries. 30. India Survived & Rebuilt itself after Centuries of Foreign Invasions & Colonization. 🤔 Actions of Individuals ≠ Actions of 1.4 Billion Indians.
Defends Indians against discrimination and hate speech using ethical arguments about generalization, stereotyping, and human dignity.
MrNilutpalN Feb 20, 2026
We as Americans are making too many enemies across the world. This isn’t good.
We as Americans are making too many enemies across the world. This isn’t good.
Moral concern about U.S. foreign relations and the negative consequences of antagonizing other nations.
@Polemic-2525 Mar 4, 2025
it's funny how older immigrants that feel something is taken away from them by new immigrants. the same way whites feel about none white immigrants
it's funny how older immigrants that feel something is taken away from them by new immigrants. the same way whites feel about none white immigrants
Makes ethical argument about hypocrisy and fairness by comparing older immigrants' attitudes to white Canadians' attitudes toward non-white immigrants.
rmacapobre Oct 11, 2025
Seriously they are paying taxes. And you live on benefits. Stop the crap
Seriously they are paying taxes. And you live on benefits. Stop the crap
Appeals to fairness and economic contribution of immigrants while defending them against criticism, combining moral principle with solidarity.
Vangaurd979 Dec 26, 2025
Am so sad that USA continues to bully not only Americans but all those countries that we worked with previous years. GOD IS NOT PLEASED WITH HOW AMERICA IS TREATING OUR NEIGHBORS. STAND IN UNITY …
Am so sad that USA continues to bully not only Americans but all those countries that we worked with previous years. GOD IS NOT PLEASED WITH HOW AMERICA IS TREATING OUR NEIGHBORS. STAND IN UNITY PRAYING GOD WILL SHOW UP. ??
Appeals to moral and religious principles condemning US treatment of neighboring countries, calling for unity and divine intervention.
@lisahatchett6125 Mar 4, 2025
The huge issue is that most white people have got advantage of centuries of colonisation of african, asian countries and they never ever want to talk about it. Now when they bring globalisation and get …
The huge issue is that most white people have got advantage of centuries of colonisation of african, asian countries and they never ever want to talk about it. Now when they bring globalisation and get people from developing countries, they have their first world complaints like crowding, driving problems... Before colonization, Many asian countries were richest and most advanced in their public systems of sewage, trade, education.. So how did these countries became developing nations now?? Centuries of colonization where wealth was stolen, people were made to be slaves, mass genocides, destruction of local industries, education system, all of these pulled the countries down. So white people if you cannot adjust to a little overcrowding, culture differences... Then pay back reparations to all former colonies with interest and none of the people from these countries will come into your country
Appeals to historical justice and reparations as ethical foundation for immigration policy, framing Western complaints as morally illegitimate.
Kalappaikaaran Mar 3, 2026
Call himself lower class trash but thinks he’s better than all Africans… wow
Call himself lower class trash but thinks he’s better than all Africans… wow
Critiques perceived hypocrisy and racism in someone's self-identification and attitudes toward Africans.
ransom182 Jan 29, 2026
silent racists if this white guy did it to black people the horror would have been international news
silent racists if this white guy did it to black people the horror would have been international news
Argues that the video creator's criticism would be treated as racism if directed at Black people, invoking double-standard fairness claims.
nmb7902 Jan 27, 2026
So native Canadians are white English people? Do you know how Canada was invaded and by whom.
So native Canadians are white English people? Do you know how Canada was invaded and by whom.
Questions the legitimacy of European-descended Canadians claiming native status, invoking historical injustice and colonial critique.
revelation333 Jan 27, 2026
« Prev 33 / 144 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)