Skip to content
Canadian Immigration Dashboard [ CID ]
Research Tools

Discourse Analysis

Semantic discourse categories assigned by Claude Haiku — 14 DH-informed categories classifying how commenters frame their arguments.

Comments Labeled
44,412
of 487,977 total
Coverage
9.1%
of eligible comments
Categories Active
14
of 14 discourse types
Avg Confidence
0.807
classifier confidence
Model
Claude Haiku
multi-label classification

Search & Filter

Search comment text, filter by category or video
Clear all

Economic Argument

1,276 comments
Page 29 of 64
Rich people like inflation. The last scorching inflation we had in the 80s, CDs for 3 years and only 10,000 dollars drew 13.5%, there was also high, high, high unemployment, home loans were 18.5% interest …
Rich people like inflation. The last scorching inflation we had in the 80s, CDs for 3 years and only 10,000 dollars drew 13.5%, there was also high, high, high unemployment, home loans were 18.5% interest with good credit. This set the farmers up or losing their farms and the Savings and Loan collapse and the subsequent 113 Billion Bail out. This was WITHOUT gutting our federal agencies, cutting back on SNAP and Medicaid and firing federal employees and gutting the agencies' ability to do oversight with the Offices of Inspector General. I can't even tell you why Dept. of Defenses is calling off our cyber defenses against Russia who hacks everything in America nuclear power plants, hydro, etc. Got my gas today - our refineries are fitted for Canadian oil though it's not a 25% tariff but Canada could slap an export tax on it to be paid by us.
Extended discussion of inflation, interest rates, unemployment, and economic policy impacts with historical examples.
@shihtzusrule9115 Mar 4, 2025
How can this be good for America? I am not buying it. The tariffs I mean, the speech was excellent! :)
How can this be good for America? I am not buying it. The tariffs I mean, the speech was excellent! :)
Expresses skepticism about tariffs' economic impact while praising the speech itself, focusing on economic policy concerns.
@karlis6235 Mar 4, 2025
?? USA! Tariffs make money for the Gov. Makes businesses WANT to come to the US to avoid tariffs. And makes American made goods more affordable compared to the out sourced goods. ?? Good bye …
?? USA! Tariffs make money for the Gov. Makes businesses WANT to come to the US to avoid tariffs. And makes American made goods more affordable compared to the out sourced goods. ?? Good bye Canadian economy ?? ? ?
Discusses tariff economics and their effects on business location and pricing, with comparative framing about US vs Canadian economies.
@Alex-op9ox Mar 4, 2025
37T in US debt. We’ve been unfairly treated the past 60 years from unfair trades from the world and Trump was the only President to say “enough”. What’s fair when US pays tariffs on goods …
37T in US debt. We’ve been unfairly treated the past 60 years from unfair trades from the world and Trump was the only President to say “enough”. What’s fair when US pays tariffs on goods but we can’t charge other countries. Let’s make trades fair. No more charities to the world paid for by US taxpayers.
Commenter argues for fair trade practices and criticizes US subsidies to other nations, framing tariffs as necessary economic correction.
@bobbykim3289 Mar 4, 2025
Canada only spends 1.3% of their GDP on defense because they depend on the US to protect them.. maybe they should contribute more to their defense or give some of the money that they do …
Canada only spends 1.3% of their GDP on defense because they depend on the US to protect them.. maybe they should contribute more to their defense or give some of the money that they do not spend on defense to the US
Analyzes Canada's defense spending as percentage of GDP and argues for reallocation of resources, focusing on economic and budgetary priorities.
@tplatt1234-r9t Mar 4, 2025
It's going to be a lot easier for other countries to boycott American good than for us to avoid buying tariffed imports because nothing is made here. We are SO fucked.
It's going to be a lot easier for other countries to boycott American good than for us to avoid buying tariffed imports because nothing is made here. We are SO fucked.
Analyzes economic consequences of tariffs and trade policy with underlying anxiety about national vulnerability.
@jbonesrva9679 Mar 4, 2025
Good step by government Canadians first great news for Canadian kids having hard time to find jobs
Good step by government Canadians first great news for Canadian kids having hard time to find jobs
Frames immigration restriction as economically beneficial to Canadian citizens seeking employment.
BabaJohn-l3x Jan 11, 2026
I hate how many indians have infested our country, make cost of living skyrocket. Its not racist, its just straight facts.
I hate how many indians have infested our country, make cost of living skyrocket. Its not racist, its just straight facts.
Claims ethnic group causes housing inflation while defensively denying racism, framing economic grievance as factual rather than prejudicial.
falconpunch6360 Jan 27, 2026
This is not a trade war. This is recouping the money that other country's owe us. PAY WHAT YOU OWE OR PAY THE TARRIF. IT'S SIMPLE.WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR COUNTRY
This is not a trade war. This is recouping the money that other country's owe us. PAY WHAT YOU OWE OR PAY THE TARRIF. IT'S SIMPLE.WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR COUNTRY
Frames tariffs as debt collection and economic justice, asserting that the US is not responsible for other countries' welfare while defending protectionist policy.
@dixieland9959 Mar 4, 2025
Always protect the culture of the place but Indians are also contributing to the economy higher than average per person
Always protect the culture of the place but Indians are also contributing to the economy higher than average per person
Balances cultural preservation concerns with economic contribution data, presenting a nuanced economic argument.
depanjanghosh5231 Jan 27, 2026
The tax cut is peanuts and it’s more than offset by increases in other taxes so we will actually pay more. Never trust a Liberal.
The tax cut is peanuts and it’s more than offset by increases in other taxes so we will actually pay more. Never trust a Liberal.
Argues that tax cuts are offset by other tax increases, resulting in net economic harm to citizens.
rdl8878 Jan 12, 2026
I just looked it up. Per capita Canada has a higher inflation rate and per capita Canada has more homeless people than America
I just looked it up. Per capita Canada has a higher inflation rate and per capita Canada has more homeless people than America
Presents economic statistics (inflation, homelessness) comparing Canada and America per capita to challenge a narrative.
@Robertnoparty Mar 4, 2025
You just don’t want to lose the billions of dollars we Americans give you yearly
You just don’t want to lose the billions of dollars we Americans give you yearly
Frames the dispute in terms of financial aid and economic dependency, comparing relative contributions between nations.
@tomgrossi4431 Mar 4, 2025
Close the borders. Nobody seems to be employing canadians under 24 anymore
Close the borders. Nobody seems to be employing canadians under 24 anymore
Commenter links border policy to employment outcomes for young Canadians, framing immigration as economically harmful to domestic job prospects.
googleuser9009 Aug 2, 2025
I for one would be happy to live in Canada and pay taxes to them instead of the US. Open your doors, Canada, and you will get people investing in your economy. Mass exodus.
I for one would be happy to live in Canada and pay taxes to them instead of the US. Open your doors, Canada, and you will get people investing in your economy. Mass exodus.
Personal willingness to immigrate framed around economic benefits (tax contribution, investment) and policy openness.
@CSLakin Mar 4, 2025
If your country is so good stay ther it’s all students it’s a scam they get in to go to school and they stay you get a big cheaque a car a job and a …
If your country is so good stay ther it’s all students it’s a scam they get in to go to school and they stay you get a big cheaque a car a job and a home what about Canadians that are homeless they can’t get nothing because Thers no address and Thers no phone so how can you get money not all are drug addicts that are homeless wen you see a woman get out of her car with two kids take them to day care and go to work if you got a job and no shower no nothing this is wrong this poor lady it made me want to cry two kids mom and a car living like a vagrant because others from other country’s have the apts a nice home and we got shit
Focuses on resource allocation and economic disparity, arguing immigrants receive benefits while homeless Canadians are neglected, combining economic and fairness concerns.
JeffLeblanc-k6b Aug 25, 2025
From Kentucky... These tariffs are a lose-lose situation all around for everyone. And.when you mess with my state's bourbon industry, Trump, then you'll be persona non grata here in the Bluegrass State.
From Kentucky... These tariffs are a lose-lose situation all around for everyone. And.when you mess with my state's bourbon industry, Trump, then you'll be persona non grata here in the Bluegrass State.
Discusses economic impact of tariffs on specific industries while implicitly calling for political consequences against Trump.
@TiggerToo27 Mar 4, 2025
Indians can't help it if you €₹@€ke₹$ are too lazy to work and keep their country functional. The reason business owners prefer hiring Indians we are simply better at doing the job, and don't act …
Indians can't help it if you €₹@€ke₹$ are too lazy to work and keep their country functional. The reason business owners prefer hiring Indians we are simply better at doing the job, and don't act entitled. You want Canadians to keep jobs in Canada, simply work harder stop crying like a little bitch about everything and be a good employee. Or get of your arse and start a business. You are not unemployed because you are being discriminated against, you are simply being outcompeted by people willing to work harder. The harsh truth of life.
Argues that Indian workers are hired due to superior work ethic and competitiveness, framing employment outcomes through economic merit rather than discrimination.
ShauryaMashruwala-y5d Jan 29, 2026
If significant numbers of people have not/do not pay taxes in Canada to support our health and welfare system then their use of those same systems weaken them for those who do. The weaken systems …
If significant numbers of people have not/do not pay taxes in Canada to support our health and welfare system then their use of those same systems weaken them for those who do. The weaken systems will start to fail and we’ll all be worse off unless, of course, we raise taxes or borrow more. How liberal is that!
Analyzes fiscal sustainability of welfare systems based on tax contribution rates of immigrants.
ASmith-u6w Feb 27, 2026
As a tax paying Canadian rather see my taxes go here than Ukraine
As a tax paying Canadian rather see my taxes go here than Ukraine
Argues that tax dollars should prioritize domestic immigration spending over foreign aid, framing as economic allocation question.
Man-UsLLP Dec 25, 2025
« Prev 29 / 64 Next »

Compare Videos

Select 2–4 videos to compare their discourse profiles side by side (% of labeled comments).

Discourse Taxonomy

Click a category to filter comments

Category Distribution

Primary discourse type assigned to each comment

Classifier Confidence

Distribution of confidence scores across all labeled comments

Discourse Over Time

Top 6 discourse types by month — how framing evolves over time

Category Co-occurrence

Which discourse types most frequently appear together on the same comment

Top Channels by Discourse Type

Which YouTube channels attract each type of discourse
Identity Assertion
CNN 2,313
Tyler Oliveira 1,991
RocaNews 467
JamCan 274
Yoke Immigration Canada 89
Solidarity
CNN 4,297
Tyler Oliveira 400
RocaNews 75
JamCan 36
CTV Your Morning 32
Policy Critique
CNN 3,445
Tyler Oliveira 551
Toronto Sun 340
CTV News 268
RocaNews 235
Humor / Satire
CNN 2,078
Tyler Oliveira 1,667
RocaNews 241
Global News 89
CTV News 68
Fear / Threat
Tyler Oliveira 1,549
CNN 1,332
RocaNews 321
JamCan 204
Toronto Sun 118
Meta-Commentary
Tyler Oliveira 1,702
CNN 1,478
RocaNews 168
CTV News 81
JamCan 77
Unverified Claim
CNN 1,480
Tyler Oliveira 820
RocaNews 203
Yoke Immigration Canada 203
JamCan 152
Moral Argument
CNN 1,733
Tyler Oliveira 704
RocaNews 205
JamCan 73
CTV Your Morning 23
Classified by Claude Haiku (Anthropic) | 14-category DH taxonomy | Search | Discourse Quality (Perspective API)