Close Reading

The comment section shows how bigoted the Indians themselves are. Yes with communal , caste, regional and class divide existing in India it’s not surprising.

by that logic majority of races are not natives, also whats wrong with this comment section she's in no position to say that to someone else. \n\nAlso people get opinion of your own, instead of just wanting validation to go with rest of comment section.

Remember the people who are making fun of her in comment section should realize that for any citizen when the population of outsiders or immigrants increases it will be concerning for them too. Imagine if all of the the sudden population of Bangladeshi immigrants increases in our country wouldn't that be trouble for us or concerning for us?? Think about it. HYPOCRITES ??

The comment sections speaks reality. Read all the comments you will have fair idea about germany.

Based on the interviews and the comment section, the younger highly educated skilled immigrant workers know very well the value of their work. The german system still have this impression that it can exploit the new generation of immigrants the way they did the older ones.

Caution: lookm at the comment section at your own risk

I am glad there aren't trolls blaming indians in comment section.

Just in this comment section, I've seen so far posts from the UK, Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, Germany, and the US, saying it's the same thing in their countries. So where is it that is so much better?

Idk why people in this comment section think that mass deportation is going to do anything \n\nYall gonna complain about something anyways

Good riddance. Yikes this YouTube \n comments section is depressing. Not everyone feels this way. Good luck in your next country.

John Stossel’s new video is stoking a lot of Muslim hate in the comments section. Check it out.

who cares what colonial illegals think they should go back to their planet and get out of ours quit using everything indian hindus made including that language you are using and i can type a huge list.Canada is not your land and as for those people you call indians they are actually punjabi. as for the land your people stole those are native indians get out of their land why didnt your people come to their country the right way why didnt your people assimilate and integrate to society rather than plunder genocide them genocide the buffallo to extinction and then have the nerve to complain take your stupid shill videos comment section down this should be reported for marginalizing a race and brewing racial bigotry. you are only going to get yourself into total isolation from the financial system and housing the healthcare so if i was you i would shut the .. uP.. you anglos are the real genociders real invaders.also quit using prefabricated houses surgery writing wireless communications airplanes toilets airplanes dentistry university cotton clothing wool those are all IndiAs intellectual property and not yours to be blunt and straight to the point honest.besides the indians achievements you should also stop using fiber optics that came from punjabis .

Every hindu in comment section having a field day ?

I'm completing my college degree in engineering and will start doing my last semester here in Germany. Looking from the outside I was amused by the German excellence, its safety and opportunities it seemed to have. In my 4 months stay learning Germany 5 years ago it also seamed like a good choice. \n\nBut now looking at the comment section and my A2 german, this dream of trying to live here feels more like a temporary 6 months stay than an opportunity for a new life.

In the comments section, I see a lot of Canadians whining about Indians, but funny enough I didn't see a single comment talking about role of Trudeau who is actually responsible for this situation. I am willing to bet that he will be back in power. ?

So as an indian living in canada as an international student right now i would like to answer the few questions here which i guess the people in video aren’t able to so your 1 st question was that why would anyone like to come in this stolen land if there is lot of racism and injustice so as an i answer i would say the racism which you can see in comment section of this video itself about “deporting” is adressed in similar scenarios i have seen as yoi see the comment section there are very annoying comments such as “imagine the smell” so i would like to say that not everyone came here are workers in tim hartons and gas stations indians are also at the highest post in corporate sectors and indeed in restaurant businesses so to identify all of the indians same as many other is inappropriate , the people with no skillset and proper planning should be deported because no country needs labours or people without any kind of skill .the main demand of people protesting is to give them a chance as the people who came as international students have many debts to pay but neglecting that fact immigration control is responsibility of government not the immigrants .so at last i would say every problem has a solution don’t stick to the problem find the solution

Most indians come to canada in search for better job oppurtunities. Also most of the comment section is ( im not trying to be racist ) but from white people. Try and see from the perspective of the indians. Even though people in india try to clean their country, its still not hygene and there are better job opportunities and education in canada

There should be a law that CBC cannot close the comment section! CBC is fed by our tax dollars but it blocks our voice!

Ruled by Invader for nearly a 1000 years, now even after 77 years of independence they are still sitting at rank 141 in per capita ( 131 after ppp adjustment) with a meagre $ 4 trillion economy inspite having abundant natural resources, unbelievable talent and a rich history... one can only imagine the level of arrogance if they ever make it to the top 50 list, let alone top 10... \nBy the way this illiterate Punjabi immigration and Microsoft tech support scam is pretty recent, started in 2018.. thanks to youtube comments section, the Indian dumb arrogance in in full display for the world to see....

The comment section here is much more informative than the video. I, too, came to germany, got my degree here and realise how manipulative the system is. Its a cycle of sabotage, for you to give your most vital resources (time, money, energy and skills) to a country that will never make you truly feel welcome.

I’m hate the comment section is enabling his calmness. When people treat you like this, you need to respond and stand up for yourself. Remaining calm is a priority, but stand up for yourself!

Comment section is so demotivating and heart breaking because I want to expand my career in Germany through Ausebildung/or vocational training but I am also student of ACCA{Management and Accounting} from South Asia.

This comment section is really lacking in empathy and making assumptions.

citynews - trumpian cesspool of canadian comment section. love listening to all the immigrants from wherever complaining about the immigrants from wherever.

Jesus this comment section is Kick levels of toxic.

It’s quite funny - the government and the states just have to look at the comment section of this video to realise what is wrong and what needs to change… but nothing will change and they will keep enticing people in to replace those that are leaving. The cycle continues

The comments section should be a mandatory read for present and future leaders of Canada. In addition, alot of Canadian resources have been sold to foreign interests. How concerned do you think they are with the local effects?

Why is there a lot of talk about refugees and students in the comments section. Can someone please educate me

reading the comment section ,i can clearly deduce Germany future is screwed

The fact that the comment section being enabled for this video but not on the one about Canadian Nectar Products Inc speaks volumes about the integrity of this show.

Warning. This comment section is too Based ? for Vice.

Someone was complaining that Canadian Passport has gotten weaker and he had to apply for an e-visa to India in the comment section. The world is getting fair and even - as it should.\n\nImagine how much the so-called 'First-World' countries make just through VISA REJECTIONS. I am happy I was born in this era - not 50 years before or 50 years after. \n \n8000+ years of human history have taught us that ''Every Empire has fallen.'' Wealth doesn't run beyond 3 generations very often. Canada had no real history 400 years ago. It had its peak in the 2000s. Now, we are past that.

12:39 THIS is racism from a journalist. Everyone that is not for open borders is a person with no hope for Canada. Why did no one in the comment section point it out?

Entire comment section is just thrashing DW left and right ?

Without judgement I think the majority of the comment section share a similar opinion

It's a miracle that this comment section is still active.

The lack of knowledge in this comment section is alarming..

Imagine if the roles were reversed and Mr. Singh didn't pay rent, I'm sure y'all would flood the comments section w hate/racist comments. (Not commenting on the tenant's identity but simply commenting how people always hate on Punjabi community specifically even though crime has no common background).

Global News deserves thanks for keeping the comment section open so people can express themselves, as opposed to a less transparent Canadian news organization.

Most ppl in the comments section were complaining about immigration. What they don't know is that there's a weak demand for investment in a country where companies expect a falling population of customers. If birth rates continue to fall down then the government will have no choice but to lure immigrants to boost population. It would be worse without immigrants as living standards would stagnate as the population gradually vanishes.

I am so pleased to see so much common sense in a Guardian comments section! ? I am anti the bs that’s going on in the west but came here to have my pov challenged, seems we’re all in agreement ????

Wow the Guardian left the comments section on-progress or did they just forget to turn it off...?

This comments section stinks

As a child of immigrants, I have to say I’m pleasantly surprised at how sane and policy-based this comments section is when the issue is so aggravating to the public. It goes to show how badly the government at all levels has fumbled, and I can speak from my own experience that most immigrants and children of immigrants agree that we cannot let this many immigrants into the country without better integration and housing availability. It does not benefit ANYONE.

Why does this comment section look like you all are mad that there arent anymore white people in Canada? ....when the original Canadians were never white? LOL It's like the craziest irony

Lmao this whole comment section is shitting on VICE biased opinions lol. Rip VICE

Wtf is wrong with this comment section ?

The homeless dude at @6:40 is in better shape than 99% of the folks in this comment section including myself ?

'Guardian' couldn't run the same report on Britain - the comments section would be full of terrorist attacks, corrosion of democracy, names of the dead.

I'm sorry to say but a immigrant cannot steal your job. A immigrant cannot take your apartment. You and your shortcomings cannot be blamed on everybody else. And that's what humans do you blame the government when the government don't fix it. We look for someone else to blame. The commenters in this section remind me of the people rioting in Britain right now