Close Reading

Nitish Brother I’m from Punjab and I really really appreciate your work. really a Big thanks to you bro. Thanks for raising our voice. Because currently this Modi government introduced our selves as a Khalistani or Atankvaadi. Every punjabi who wear a turban is donated as a Khalistani. This image is created by this government in the whole India. We are very weak now our economy our culture is in danger zone. political peoples destroyed us on the basis of religion. Unemployment is on peak but nobody watching us except this Khalistani badge. Every sikh is not khalistani. just imagine if any person who gives harms to the mandir how will you accept it?\nWe are very possessive about our religion A punjab gives food to every people of India or the world because our gurus teach us that. but nobody care for us. All of them just pinch the nerve of our religion for votes and if you know punjabies are paying 20 lakh₹ to go for canada today. because of these issues. i want to say this to whole India “Guys please come out of this religious war these political peoples just dividing us. You guys knows that before modi in India there was not any issue of Hindu/Sikh or muslim. Because they needs votes for 2024 elections that’s why they are using this method” So, pls I request to the every indian support the india do not divide India?

When you make next part bro..Must include chandigarh issue..we don’t have our capital..we are not getting single penny rom chandigarh GDP because its a UT..how many states of India dosn’t have Capital? Everyone who reads my comment just imagine if Mumbai will become UT Maharashtra ka kyo hoga..same Ahmedabad and Chennai and Kolkata ..Every state has developed capitals but we don’t have..one more thing you missed in 80’s to 90’ there are thousands of fake encounters in Punjab and their next generations is in abroad right now..they don’t have any patriotic. Feelings for India because their parents were killed in fake encounters..Nijjar family also killed

As a Sikh, I feel you are one of the very few unbiased presenters that also shows the rightful grievances of the Sikhs against the government, otherwise most Indian YouTubers just repeat the government propaganda points which deliberately and wrong target and label minorities, they think they’re nationalists but in reality just jingoists who need to learn what actually patriotism is from the Sikhs in Punjab and Indian army which is service, dividing communities is not being a patriot, it is inherently bad for India the more divisions andhbhakts create, your unbiased and well researched videos are much appreciated brother, keep up the good work Nitish ??\n\nP.s. - this is what an average Sikh thinks about Khalistan https://youtu.be/QpcAGJUcIzw?si=OGeX8DBLXXZdPaAA

Correction: You are showing the correct map of India pre-independence but not showing correct map of Punjab pre-independence. The eastern part of Punjab contained present day Haryana and Himachal Pradesh too. Let people also know how big Maha Punjab was and what it is made today by Indian government.

I am from Punjab and I moved to Canada in 2020. I really appreciate that Nitin has tried putting forward all the major factors that are pushing today's youth to migrate to Foreign countries. Punjabis have not just migrated to Canada, Australia and England, there are so many people who have been going to Arab countries for their livelihood. The major push factors at this time I would say are unemployment, drugs and poor politics. Most of the people simply wants a good peaceful life for themselves being a part of India.

Thanks alottt Nitish Bro for making this video and Spreading Awareness that we all Sikh's are not Khalistani's...Hum to India mein aaram se reh rahe hai aur agar Hum Canada move bhi hote hai to sirf unemployment ki wajah se proper Jobs achi Salary vali Jobs Naa hone ki wajah se...Aur Punjab se sirf SIKH's hi Nahi Punjabi HINDU's bhi Canada move hote hai for Better Future...\nYeh to Canada mein Baithe kuch Vehle Lok hai jo aise Mudhe baar baar uthate hai, Hamara unse koi Lena Dena Nahi hai...Un Logo ko koi Kaam Dhanda hai Nahi, Khalistani Issues pae Logo ko Murakh bana ke unhe Kaafi Paisa Funding ke Roop mein mil jaata hai jis wajah se un Logo ko Paisa kamane ki Ghar chalane ki koi Chinta Nahi, isliye wo sabb Vehle Baithe New Generation ka Mindwash krne ki Koshish krte rehte hai...Canada mein kaafi Hard Life hoti hai so Youth ke paas in Faaltu Kamo ke liye Time hi Nahi hai...Waha Mehnat krke unhe Acha Lifestyle milta hai, PR aur Citizenship lene ke baare baaki Canadians ke jaise Sabhi Sahulate milti hai Sabhi Rights milte hai Acha Khasa Paisa kama lete hai so Hum Log isi mein Khush hai...

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

One third of erstwhile Punjab is in India and the rest in Pakistan. Why are they demanding separate Khalistan from India and not from Pakistan ??

Sikhs,Punjabis are very hardworking..In India much was done to exploit the youth by making them drug addicts and drunkards..parents cannot control..so they send them to any country..to do.any job ..but be out of our house..as.the patrents get harassed due to daily fights.. please Punjabis send your children to Gurudwara..attend and arrange satsangs..in every galli of Punjab..atrange langar for all hungry all over ..teach GURUBAANI..SHABADS..involve youth in seva at Gurudwara...open drug deaddiction centres in every galli...do not depend on Govt...you must contribute whatever possible and save.Punjab...Your neighbouring country pummping drug misguiding youth..do not forget Punjabi ladies breast cut off during partition by these people who are your beighbour..do not believe them

Why does people even immigrant outside in a herd, Indian are leaving their country it's sad, all thanks to our shitty govt, they're not resolving anything. We're literally hopeless. People loves to mock us. Why people making other countries crowded, they'd of course hate it. Canada is called second Punjab, don't u think they feel bad about that? Canada's govt should do something about that and our govt too, so that people don't feel like leaving India. I hate it when they do it, Just like when people from Bengal illegally enter my state Assam. So hopeless.

Great documentary, but in my opinion, it's terribly one-sided, portraying these colleges as villains and the students as poor, innocent victims. As a former international student from India myself, who had the privilege of attending a prestigious university in the UK, working there, and moving on, the workings of this situation are as clear as daylight and as old as the hills. \nIt wasn't any different back then in the UK 20 years ago, during the heady Blair days, when UK colleges significantly increased their intake of international students, aided by a lax visa regime. This was also in response to tighter visa restrictions in the US following 9/11. Students enrolling in such colleges, as well as the parents funding them, are well aware that these are degree mills. The sole aim here is to somehow navigate through college and stay long enough until permanent residency comes through. \nTears flow and protests erupt only when this unspoken but clearly understood agreement is broken, often with the media conveniently at hand. The reasons driving this insatiable urge are multifarious, but poverty and lack of opportunities in the country (in this case, India) do not really rank high on the list. Social prestige and an imagined better life in the 'West' certainly do, particularly among young people from states like Punjab, Haryana, and parts of Gujarat. \nNothing about this is illegal, and not to sound cynical, these are market forces at work. However, in my view, this represents a more accurate truth. It would be great to see Fifth Estate also report from this side

What was the crime of Little Girl who just had a Tattoo of Tricolor and was stopped from entering Sri Harmandir Saheb in Punjab, India, the origin and birth place of Sikhism?? Yeapp, its Sad. But, then why play a Victim card when you, yourself are no less?? And, lets not forget, thats not Punjab and definitely not INDIA.

South India students are good in education and English . Punjab people are poor. I'm not against North India just saying. This agents scam should be stopped many good people lossing money against this basteard

Sikhs use even more dirty racist languages against biharis working in Punjab. Indians are superb hypocrites. If foreign countries are so racist then why the hell Indians love to go their even illegally. There are half million illegal Indians immigrants in the USA and I'm not even talking about Canada which is cesspool of illigal immigrants from India and Pakistan.

And there is one important fact that you missed in this documentary. It is Indian(racial) people taking advantage of these young India people like us not Canadians! The same immigrants who immigrated to Canada from India couple years ago are taking advantages of new people coming now. These private colleges are run by India nationals to make profit from recruiting people from Punjab. And India landlords taking advantages of new international India students and it is Indian (racial) employers who is taking advantage of international students to do more work!

Work 74 years to pay 1 year’s tuition? Really??\n\nI know that 1 CAD will get you approx. 60 INR, but wages have increased dramatically in India, so I don’t know how the math was done to assert that it would take 74 years to pay 1 year’s tuition.\n\nI checked Alpha college’s tuition fee for 4 semesters or two years, and it’s $31,130 or $15,565 for 1 year, which, in today’s market exchange rate is, less than INR 940,000. \n\nI know and have several relatives in India who makes anywhere between CAD equivalent of $8000 and $20000 per year. Not sure what the wages are in Punjab, but can’t imagine that assertion is correct. Irrespective, I know that even CAD $15,565 is very high for most Indian families.

Achha hoga Canada....but our India and Punjab is best ...a kite flying in sky should not forget its thread are on land and the day thread is cut off...kite has to land on earth only...

Trust me the only reason I would never move to Canada would be coz of Punjabi’s. Canada doesn’t look like Canada anymore but more like Punjab and it’s not gonna get any better if they don’t stop letting people come in. Canada gotta stop letting every Tom dick and Harry come in. And yes I am myself a Punjabi. These people are taking the opportunity of being able to come to Canada for granted. They don’t know how to respect the laws of land. They didn’t know it back in India and are not willing to learn either.

Not all punjabis have relatives in Brampton or Canada or other immigrant flooded countries.\n\nMaybe they and their ancestors are happy the way they are in punjab or maybe they are skilled enough to make more money than Canada in India\n\nOur all bullshit video

It is super dirty . Mumbai and other big cities are cleaner than that . Punjab is not India, it is very small part of India.